In the still life photography class I'm taking, Kim Klassen posted a couple prompts on "found" still lifes or real life still lifes. Basically, scenes from your life which look like or qualify as still lifes. She included a photograph from her yard. It made me think about the difference between still life photography and nature photography. Kim's approach to still life photography is that it's about the process - about breathing and finding quiet, stillness and peace. And she suggested that you can find that without posing or choreographing a photograph. While I was in Oregon, I tried to find an appropriate nature still life. I took the photograph above. What do you think? Is that a still life? I think it's a beautiful photograph, and it captures stillness and peace. I'm glad I took it and it's one of the types of photographs I love to take. But, to me, the thing I have liked about the still life photography class has been the creating, posing and choreographing of shots. It's kind of like creating a painting or drawing but using props and my camera instead. I didn't think nature photography could be still life photography.
And then this happened. I was walking to work, and I "found" this scene. The lighting, the colors, and the composition all screamed "still life" to me. So I got out my iphone and captured the image. And now I think I get what Kim was getting at. There are some still lifes, some vignettes, out there to be found in nature. They have been posed by an unseen hand, but posed nonetheless. Created to draw the viewer in and experience peace and quiet. And stillness. Thoughts?
I agree that the first photo conveys a feeling of stillness and peace but it doesn't say 'still life' to me. I'd categorise it as a nature photo. The second one I would call a 'still life' - it's lovely and I wish I'd seen it myself.
I don't see the first photo as a still life, but the second one definitely is. I know I've found some nature photos like that, but I've never really thought of them as still life. This was a helpful post. :-)
NATURAL ALWAYS TAKES THE LEAD you have wonderful blog, i followed your blog, please follow back. thank you http://melodyjacob1.blogspot.com/ #havealovelyweek
NATURAL ALWAYS TAKES THE LEAD you have wonderful blog, i followed your blog, please follow back. thank you http://melodyjacob1.blogspot.com/ #havealovelyweek
Not being a photographer, I guess I hadn't really thought about photos fitting into different boxes. I see all pictures as telling a story, whether it's composed or found. I'm interested in her idea of emphasizing the "still" in still life
interesting distinction - I love both photos but for the sake of categorising I'd say only the 2nd is still life - which to me instinctively includes at least one object on a surface
what a fascinating post - I know that there are some vignettes I see that do 'feel' like a still life. I like the different thoughts here. Thank you for sharing.
1. A "wild heart" - a naturally occurring heart (like the rock above, but it doesn't have to be a rock) 2. A footprint or pawprint 3. A skeleton, bone or x-ray 4. A book or magazine read during 2016 5. A porch or deck 6. A camper (caravan) 7. A family gathering 8. A drawing, art project, artistic photograph, scrapbook page, greeting card, or art journal page created by you. 9. Someone playing with, in, or around water. 10. A bicycle 11. Fresh produce 12. A window 13. The moon 14. A buffet of food 15. A team logo 16. A map showing a trip taken during the time period 17. Twins 18. A supermarket cart, basket or trolley full of groceries 19. A seasonal cocktail or beverage 20. Someone laughing 21. A photograph of you with a newspaper or calendar page from the time period covered in the Hunt. Note: you may not use a substitute for this item. Alternatives - if you're having trouble finding any of the above, you may substitute from this list (but you may not substitute for item #21): alternative 1: a lighthouse alternative 2: a baby (human or animal)
![LEAP [into lightroom]](http://learn.kimklassen.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/Kim-Klassen_20151223_6459.jpg)
Posts
13 comments:
I agree that the first photo conveys a feeling of stillness and peace but it doesn't say 'still life' to me. I'd categorise it as a nature photo. The second one I would call a 'still life' - it's lovely and I wish I'd seen it myself.
A very interesting post. Thank you.
Yep, agreed. Your two shots illustrate the point perfectly and are lovely.
I don't see the first photo as a still life, but the second one definitely is. I know I've found some nature photos like that, but I've never really thought of them as still life. This was a helpful post. :-)
That second photo definitely looks like a still life to me!
NATURAL ALWAYS TAKES THE LEAD
you have wonderful blog,
i followed your blog, please follow back. thank you
http://melodyjacob1.blogspot.com/ #havealovelyweek
NATURAL ALWAYS TAKES THE LEAD
you have wonderful blog,
i followed your blog, please follow back. thank you
http://melodyjacob1.blogspot.com/ #havealovelyweek
Not being a photographer, I guess I hadn't really thought about photos fitting into different boxes. I see all pictures as telling a story, whether it's composed or found. I'm interested in her idea of emphasizing the "still" in still life
interesting distinction - I love both photos but for the sake of categorising I'd say only the 2nd is still life - which to me instinctively includes at least one object on a surface
I don't think it matters how you categorize them as long as you enjoy taking them! But if I have to say... I agree with everyone else.
I agree with the other comments, photo 2 is definitely still life. I am taking the course but finding still life extremely difficult.
The second picture is very lovely and feels like you arranged it beautifully where as the trees were put there by nature
what a fascinating post - I know that there are some vignettes I see that do 'feel' like a still life. I like the different thoughts here. Thank you for sharing.
Interesting post. I really like both photos but to me only the 2nd one would be a still life.
Post a Comment